Buscar

Showing posts with label DOT Compliance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DOT Compliance. Show all posts

Battle lines are being drawn; labor challenges DOT’s new rule related to direct observation for urine specimen collections.

You may remember reading a couple of months ago about DOT publishing new rules for direct observation collection of urine specimens. Now, DOT is postponing implementation of some parts of that rule until November 1, 2008.

What exactly is going on?

There is definitely some confusion going on, and as an employer, you are not alone in trying to understand the issues that seem to be in question.

Let us look at what actually happened:

On June 25, 2008 DOT published a final rule addressing a number of directives related to specimen validity testing and a modification in procedures for collecting urine specimens under direct observation (DO).

Because of the wide availability of prosthetic devices for providing clean urine, and findings by the Government Accounting Office that collectors are frequently less than diligent in preventing cheating during urine specimen collections, DOT directed that all DO collections also include the employee raising his/her shirt up to the navel and lowering pants/skirt to mid thigh. This was to ensure that no prosthetic devise was concealed on their person. This procedure was explained in the DOT notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) published on October 31, 2005.

In the June 25 final rule, DOT also mandated that all return-to-duty and follow-up tests (collections) be conducted under DO. Previously, DO collections for these type of tests were an employer option. Several labor organizations petitioned DOT to suspend this requirement since it had not been discussed in the October 31, 2005 NPRM. On August 26, 2008 DOT published a notice in the Federal Register changing the implementation date (for 40.67(b) – the section addressing mandatory DO collections for return-to-duty and follow-up) from August 25 to November 1, 2008 and provided a 30-day period for interested parties to provide comments.

What does all of this mean to you?

Simply put, all DO collections will require the new procedure to raise the shirt and lower pants/skirt. As an employer, you need to make sure that your collection site(s) or Third Party Administrator is aware of this requirement and will abide by it. Second issue – requirement for DO collections for return-to-duty and follow-up tests will remain employer option – until November 1 – when DOT will make a final decision.

That sounds pretty simple and employers may question what all the fuss is about? To a large degree, it’s all a matter of misinterpretation and misunderstanding. There are about 50 comments in the DOT docket from individuals and associations providing their views on this issue. Some commenters seem to think that DO collections are a new requirement and question the procedure’s invasiveness as well as the difficulty of meeting the requirement to have the same gender observer. This is puzzling, since the DO requirement has been in existence since August 2000. One may suspect that these individuals or companies have not been conducting DO collections in the past and are now surprised and think it is a new requirement.

Individual Comments
Some comments are from individual employees who are subject to these rules. Understandably, many of them are responding to the new procedure of lifting the shirt and lowering pants/skirt as overreaching and invasive to the extreme. Many labor organizations in addition to objecting to the shirt and pants/skirt procedure are lumping together the original DO requirement and the new directive making DO mandatory for return-to-duty and follow-up testing. Their original concern was that there was no comment period for requiring DO collections for return-to-duty and follow-up. DOT is now providing a 30-day period for comments on this subject.

SAP Comments
Quite a number of comments are from substance abuse professionals (SAP) and other individuals who provide treatment to drug and alcohol abusers. Most of them favor DO collections for return-to-duty and follow-up collections on the basis that these individuals have already provided evidence that they are users and/or dependent on drugs. In the SAP’s experiences, drug addicts often revert back to their destructive behavior and will use any means possible to avoid detection of their continued drug use. Drug testing is one way to not only detect use, but to also help and deter these individuals from reverting to their drug use behavior. Additionally, some SAPs indicated that many employers are reluctant to direct DO collections for return-to-duty and follow-up tests, thereby providing a potential opportunity for an employee who already is at risk to try and cheat on a drug test. Many of the comments state that if the concern is for safety of the traveling public, then DO collections for return-to-duty and follow-up are more than appropriate.

Collection Facility Comments
A number of collection sites made comments that they would not be able to meet these new DO requirements because their entire staff is female and most of the employees requiring drug testing are male. Here again, if this is what an employer hears from a collection site, the employer needs to ask what the site is doing now to meet the current DO requirement. There were some comments suggesting that if employers/ supervisors identified an individual for testing (return-to-duty and follow-up) and then accompanied that individual to the collection site, there would be no opportunity for the employee to obtain adulterants or prosthetic devices prior to the test. That may be true, but most employers do not follow these procedures, plus a return-to-duty test is usually scheduled to a certain degree.

BOTTOM LINE: Direct observation testing, to include raising shirt and lowering pants/skirt is here to stay. An employer and/or collection site must conduct these under certain criteria spelled out in the regulations. Mandatory DO collections for return-to-duty and follow-up testing is suspended until November 1, 2008 (Note: employers currently have the option to require this type of collection.) As an employer, you have the opportunity to make comments to the DOT docket on this issue (htt;://www.regulations.gov The Docket number is OST-2003-15245). Your comments are always important.

Stay tuned to this publication; as soon as DOT makes a determination related to mandating DO collections for return-to-duty and follow-up, we will publish the information in this Newsletter.

What are an employer’s responsibilities...

...when an applicant admits to testing positive on or to refusing to take a pre-employment test within the past two years?

The Department of Transportation (DOT) drug and alcohol testing rule (49 CF Part 40) specifically spells out in Section 40.25 what an employer has to do to check an applicant’s prior alcohol and drug testing history with previous employers for whom the individual performed safety-sensitive functions during the previous two years.

Some employers do not realize that paragraph (j) of that section explicitly directs the employer to “ask the employee (i.e., applicant) whether he or she has tested positive, or refused to test, on any pre-employment drug or alcohol test administered by an employer to which the employee (applicant) applied for, but did not obtain, safety-sensitive transportation work covered by DOT agency drug and alcohol testing rules during the past two years.” What this means is that an employer or its service agent (Third Party Administrator (TPA)) must ask this question as part of the hiring process for DOT safety-sensitive positions and this needs to be documented in a manner that can satisfy an auditor.

Getting back to the original question, what is the employer to do when an applicant admits to testing positive or refusing to take a pre-employment test? Obviously, the individual did not get hired and as an employer, you need to now determine if the applicant followed all the procedures spelled out in the Federal regulations and complied with the return-to-duty requirements – that is provided you still want to hire that individual. This means that you must obtain documentation that the applicant went to a Substance Abuse Professional (SAP) for an initial evaluation, followed all the recommendations of the SAP for education and/or treatment, obtained a follow-up evaluation from the SAP, and complied with the SAP’s recommended follow-up tests.

If an applicant admits to testing positive or refusing to test on a previous pre-employment test:
This procedure looks formidable so let’s break it down to a more practical process. Probably in the majority of cases, if an applicant admits to testing positive or refusing to test on a previous pre-employment test, he/she was not hired and probably did not go to see a SAP. In that case, you may not use that individual in a safety-sensitive position until he/she goes for the initial SAP evaluation, follows the recommended program, and has a follow-up evaluation that indicates the individual has progressed to the extent that he/she can return to safety-sensitive duty. As an employer, if you want to hire this individual you are not required to pay for the SAP evaluations and education/treatment, although you may do so if it is consistent with your policy.

Verifying a that an applicant saw a SAP
Now lets suppose the applicant tells you that he/she did see a SAP and followed a program and is now ready to return to safety-sensitive duties. If you want to hire this individual you must obtain documentation of this return-to-duty process. The applicant may have documents from the SAP indicating the progression of evaluation and treatment and recommended follow-up. However, since documents can be compromised, it is always a good idea to contact the SAP and verify this information. In some cases, you may want to receive copies of these documents directly from the SAP, especially if the applicant does not have them, but is willing to have the SAP provide them to you.

If you want to hire the Applicant
We are now at the final step. As an employer, you want to hire the applicant and you have all the relevant SAP documents. In all cases, the SAP must recommend a minimum of six drug or alcohol or both tests within 12 months following return-to-duty. In most likelihood these have not been done since the applicant has not been in a safety-sensitive position. These will have to be done by you as the new employer and that is in addition to enrolling the individual into your random testing program. One final step; there is a requirement that before this individual can go back to safety-sensitive functions, he/she must have a “return-to-duty” drug and alcohol test which is negative. In most cases, DOT agency regulators have permitted this test to serve two functions and be combined into one test, i.e., as a pre-employment test and as a return-to-duty test – just make sure you document this in some manner.

Important Issues for Employers:

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s (FMCSA) rule (49 CFR Part 391) requires information from previous employers be obtained for three prior years. So, although Part 40 requests two years of alcohol and drug history from prior employers, in reality for employers who come under the authority of FMCSA this translates to three years of prior information.

As an employer if you have someone who refuses or has a positive drug or alcohol pre-employment test, you are obligated to provide that individual with several names, addresses, and telephone numbers of SAPs, even if you do not hire that individual. This information may be provided by you or your MRO or TPA and neither you nor your service agents may charge the applicant for this information.

If the applicant tells you that he/she refused or tested positive on a pre-employment test, but no documentation exists that the applicant successfully completed the return-to-duty process, a current return-to-duty process must occur before the applicant can again perform safety-sensitive functions.

If the applicant admits to a violation of the drug and alcohol testing rules, has completed all the return-to-duty procedures and is now in the follow-up stage and employed in a safety-sensitive position by another employer, and you hire this individual, you will be responsible to “finish” the follow-up testing. What this means is that the SAP may have directed that the applicant undergo 10 follow-up drug tests within the first year after returning to safety-sensitive duty and the applicant’s current employer has completed six of these tests. If you hire this individual you will have to complete the other four follow-up tests that were required as part of the SAP’s follow-up plan.

Impact on Employers of New DOT Rule Regarding Specimen Validity Testing

What exactly is SVT and why is it so important for DOT to make it mandatory? SVT is a series of procedures that drug testing laboratories are directed by the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) to conduct on all urine specimens to determine if the specimen has been adulterated or substituted and to determine if it is truly a specimen that could be produced naturally by an individual. Most laboratories were conducting some variation of SVT prior to this, but the new rule will now make it mandatory that every drug testing laboratory follow the DHHS Mandatory Guidelines for performing SVT on urine specimens collected under DOT requirements.

Over the years, there has also been an increase in products designed to adulterate specimens and their use has increased as individuals attempt to mask their use of illegal drugs. There are also various prosthetic devices on the market that store clean urine at body temperature and permit individuals to provide a urine specimen under direct observation without detection that the specimen is not actually emerging from the individual’s body.

Given these factors, DOT determined that provision of less privacy during directly observed collections would guard against individuals using these prosthetic devices to circumvent the collection process. To that extent, DOT directed that during a directly observed collection, the individual will be asked to raise his or her shirt, blouse, or dress/skirt, as appropriate, above the waist and to lower clothing and underpants to show that there are no prosthetic devices hidden under the clothing. It is also good to remember that a directly observed collection only happens when there is reason to suspect that the individual may have tampered with the specimen or because the individual had a previous non-negative result.

You may be asking yourself what does this have to do with an employer – or even with the Designated Employer Representative (DER)? You have to remember that the DOT program is one of deterrence rather then detection. Individuals need to be aware of the fact that under the new rule, all directly observed collections will require the individual to show the observer/collector that there are no prosthetic devices to interfere with the collection. Additionally, the requirement to conduct a directly observed collection is now mandatory for all return-to-duty and follow-up tests (prior to the new rule, it was optional based on employer’s policies). Knowledge that this requirement exists may prevent some individuals from using illegal drugs since one avenue of “cheating” on the test will no longer be available.

This means that as an employer or DER, you need to ensure that your safety-sensitive employees are aware of these changes. You do not want to have an individual go for a collection and be told that they have to partially disrobe. Not knowing that this is now a Federal requirement, some individuals may refuse to partially disrobe for the collector, which would be considered a refusal to test. Preparation and assurance that this is a legitimate requirement will go a long way to temper the unease that some individuals may have in regards to this new collection procedure.

New Refusal to Test Classification
By the way, when discovered, use of a prosthetic device will now be considered a refusal to test; so will refusal to wash hands and admission to the MRO of adulteration or substitution of the specimen.

The rule also modified some of the procedures and reports related to invalid results. These are defined as a “result reported by a laboratory for a urine specimen that contains an unidentified adulterant, contains an unidentified interfering substance, has an abnormal physical characteristic, or has an endogenous substance at an abnormal concentration that prevents the laboratory from completing testing or obtaining a valid drug test result.”

Here is something to remember:

If the first test is an invalid result and the second collection is also invalid for the same reason, the test will be cancelled. If there is a requirement for a negative, i.e., pre-employment or return-to-duty, the rule now requires a medical evaluation to determine if there is any evidence of illegal drug use.

If the second test is an invalid result for a different reason from the first test, the MRO will direct a third test (without discussing this with the individual). And yes, you as the employer will have to pay for all three tests. The rules are written to provide a balance between unreasonable requirements versus concern for public safety, and this is the best that DOT could do at the present time.

There is another change that the employer needs to be aware of: if the individual admits to the MRO to drug use during a verification interview related to an invalid result, the MRO will notify the DER, who then must take action under the Agency rules; in the highway industry, this is related to actual knowledge.

Another change that you and your DER need to be aware of is that if there are multiple collections for the same event (e.g., first specimen’s temperature is out of range, requiring a second collection under direct observation) and the first specimen is reported at negative, the MRO is now directed to “hold” this report until the results of the second specimen are reported by the laboratory. This was done to prevent employers from placing individuals into safety-sensitive duties based on the first negative and then subsequently receiving a positive result for the second directly observed collection. Of course, if the first specimen in non-negative (positive) the MRO will report this to the employer immediately.

An added item to remember, both for your policy updates and to inform your employees, is that there is no authorization for testing of a split specimen for a sample that has been reported as invalid. That’s pretty simple and easy to interpret.

And finally, DOT did not change the employer’s option related to negative results that are also dilute. As an employer you still have the option of requiring a re-collection (but not under direct observation) and the test result of record would be the result of the second test.

All of this sounds a lot more complicated than it is; however, the bottom line is – just follow the rules!

Note from previous Federal Corner: Last month the discussion centered on requirements directing employers, MROs, and Breath Alcohol Technicians to report refusals and positive results to several State licensing authorities.

As of May 2008, South Carolina initiated legislation to require similar reporting. As a recap, the following States now require some form of reporting: Arkansas, California, Oregon, North Carolina, South Carolina, New Mexico, Texas, and Washington.

Record Keeping – Is There an Easier Way?

Records, documents, files, paper everywhere! Are you drowning in paper or is everything in an electronic database and you are keeping it forever?

The Department of Transportation (DOT) directs employers to maintain certain records related to the drug and alcohol testing program. Additional requirements are also placed on employers by the various modal administrations (Federal Motor Carrier Administration FMCSA, Federal Aviation Administration, etc.) and are specific to that particular transportation industry. The following comments are geared primarily to employers subject to FMCSA regulations.

As an employer, you have enough problems keeping track of all the governmental and bureaucratic requirements related to your core business. Tracking record requirements for your drug and alcohol program is probably your least favorite thing. However, during an audit if these records are not up to par, you may face some serious fines. Did you know that in some cases, using a driver whose record indicates a positive test result, but does not show that the driver went through a substance abuse professional (SAP) evaluation and treatment, may subject you to a $10,000 a day fine? That is definitely not good for business.

As an employer you have a few options:
· Keep all required records yourself at your place of business.
· Keep some of your records at your place of business and other records by your Third Party Administrator (TPA) with whom you have a contract for your drug and alcohol testing program.
· Let your TPA keep all your records for you.

Here are the regulatory requirements (FMCSA) that you have to follow:

Subpart D - Handling of Test Results, Records Retention, and Confidentiality
§ 382.401 Retention of records.
(a) General requirement. Each employer shall maintain records of its alcohol misuse and controlled substances use prevention programs as provided in this section. The records shall be maintained in a secure location with controlled access.

(b) Period of retention. Each employer shall maintain the records in accordance with the following schedule:
(1) Five years. The following records shall be maintained for a minimum of five years:
(i) Records of driver alcohol test results indicating an alcohol concentration of 0.02 or greater,
(ii) Records of driver verified positive controlled substances test results,
(iii) Documentation of refusals to take required alcohol and/or controlled substances tests,
(iv) Driver evaluation and referrals,
(v) Calibration documentation,
(vi) Records related to the administration of the alcohol and controlled substances testing programs, and
(vii) A copy of each annual calendar year summary required by §382.403.
(2) Two years. Records related to the alcohol and controlled substances collection process (except calibration of evidential breath testing devices).
(3) One year. Records of negative and canceled controlled substances test results and alcohol test results with a concentration of less than 0.02 shall be maintained for a minimum of one year.
(4) Indefinite period. Records related to the education and training of breath alcohol technicians, screening test technicians, supervisors, and drivers shall be maintained by the employer while the individual performs the functions which require the training and for two years after ceasing to perform those functions.

Note: Paragraph (c) of this rule text provides further descriptions of the types of records that are to be maintained. If you are maintaining your own records, you need to read this section. One other gem of wisdom from this paragraph: “If the record is required to be prepared, it must be maintained.”

This sounds like a lot of stuff to be worried about; and it is! If you opt for maintaining all files/documents yourself, then you have to follow the above requirements to the letter. If you want your TPA to maintain your files, there are a few items you need to consider.

First of all, you or the TPA must be able to produce copies of all the files needed for an audit within two business days. This can be a problem for many larger companies with multiple sites if the TPA stores the paper files exclusively in a central location. That is why maintaining electronic files with your TPA can be especially helpful because the files are always accessible to the satellite locations.

If you want to keep some files yourself and have the TPA keep other files, you need to determine who maintains which files. You don’t want to be in a situation where during an audit you think the TPA has certain files and they tell the inspector that they thought you kept the files. However, if you have the TPA image all of your documents to an electronic format, you can be assured that you always have access to any file.

So, it’s a no-brainer that if you keep your own files, you have to keep all of them for the required time spelled out in the regulations.

If a TPA maintains some of your files, you should still keep copies of the employer’s chain of custody form (CCF), the MRO results report, copies of the SAP reports, and certainly relevant documentation related to reasonable suspicion and post-accident testing. Auditors will generally want to see these “original” copies.

There are some advantages to a TPA maintaining your files. Usually, TPAs are more knowledgeable than employers as to what the regulations require and how to implement these requirements. They also have much more sophisticated computer systems on which to maintain all of these records.
For example, besides maintaining all files related to random selection and testing, data for the annual MIS report, results of all tests conducted, etc., a TPA can maintain all of your driver qualification files on their system, providing you with notifications of specific actions required to update the files, trigger various reports, arrange for medical examinations, and any other action required to maintain the files in accordance with the regulations. This can certainly remove some of the paper work burden facing an employer and streamline the whole process.

As an employer, you need to determine what other files you want the TPA to maintain for you. Do you want them to keep copies of reports explaining why a reasonable suspicion test was conducted; reports of why a post-accident alcohol or drug test was not performed within the specified time frame; alcohol and drug information from previous employers; supervisory training records, etc., or will you be more comfortable having these records at your place of business?

Once you bite the bullet and make some of these decisions, your life should get a lot easier and you will not have to panic when you hear the word audit!

Are There Holes In The DOT Drug Testing Program...

Or Are You Getting Your Money's Worth?


The Subcommittee on Highways and Transit met on November 1, 2007 and reviewed testimony related to vulnerabilities in the Drug and Alcohol Testing programs administered by motor carriers. A number of incidents prompted the Subcommittee to direct the General Accountability Office (GAO) to conduct an in-depth review of conditions at facilities that perform urine specimen collections for drug tests regulated by the Department of Transportation (DOT).

On February 19, 2007, Fox News report aired in Minneapolis, MN indicating problems in four out of five collection facilities, which afforded employees opportunities to cheat or circumvent the urine specimen collection process. Another important figure released was a recent Oregon State Police report that showed an 8.9% positive rate on their most recent roadside Operation Trucker Check. The DOT estimation of the positive drug rate is 1.7%.

To make matters worse, in 2005 GAO testified before Congress that approximately 400 products were available on the market specifically designed to beat a drug test. The lack of consistent and secure procedures in the collection facilities only seems to contribute to the Congressional concern about the effectiveness of the drug testing program.

There are a number of ways to look at these contradictory data, but suffice it to say, not all collection problems are of such nature that they would increase the possibility of someone cheating on a drug test. In fact, the high percent of positive results in the Oregon report includes the detection of prescription drugs (which DOT does not test for) and does not include potential “down grades” to negative results by a medical review officer.

So, is the program successful and are you getting your money’s worth?
You bet the program is working! Quest Diagnostics, one of the larger Health and Human Services certified drug testing laboratories, publishes a Drug Testing Index which shows a dramatic decrease in drug positive rates from 1988 to 2006: 13.6% versus 3.8% for more than 9 million tests in 2006. A breakout for Federal and DOT results indicates a positive rate for of 2.0% for 2006. You can check this out on their web site at: http://www.questdiagnostics.com/employersolutions/dti/2007_03/dti_index.html.
Drug testing in general has decreased drug usage by individuals in safety-sensitive jobs (e.g., drivers). Therefore, how could an employer increase the likelihood that a drug program will be successful?

First of all, as an employer, you have little impact on what happens at the collection site. You have to assume that the staff conducting the collections has been properly trained and are aware of procedures that hey have to use. Of course, one major problem is that urine specimen collection generally is not a clinic’s primary function and it may not receive the attention it deserves.

Lesson #1
There is nothing wrong with periodically asking one of your employees who went through the collection process to describe to you what the procedures were like or to specifically tell you if there were any actions which may have appeared as inappropriate. Of course, you have to take these second hand reports with a grain of salt, but if you hear the same potential problem from two or three of your employees, you need to take action. This could be as simple as calling the collection site and asking them what their procedure is in that particular area. (We have to assume that as an employer, you have some knowledge of what constitutes a proper collection.) If you use a third party administrator (TPA), you should pass your concerns on to them for resolution. The TPA can visit the collection site, can review their procedures, and can correct any deviations.

Lesson #2
Devote some time and thought is to your drug and alcohol policy and what it states in reference to certain procedures. For example, how much notice do you give to applicants about when they are to go for a drug test? By the way, this is really an IQ test; if you tell an applicant to take a drug test three days from now and they come back positive, not only do you not want to hire them because they are using drugs, but they are also not very smart!

Your procedure should give applicants minimal notice of when a drug test will be conducted and the process should not be predictable. The same goes for your current employees. When you tell one of them to take a drug test, what is the time span for arrival at the collection site? Do they have the whole day during which they can go to the clinic? In other words, if you tell an employee in the morning to go sometimes that day to the clinic for a drug test, that individual has all day to try and obtain some adulterants, a prosthetic device, clean urine, etc. At this point, you have just wasted your money on a drug program that will not be effective.

Your policy should state that the employee has a specific time to get to the collection site (based on travel distance, etc.) and that the only exceptions would be documented problems, such as an auto accident, emergency room visit, or abduction by space aliens. Arrival after that time is considered refusal to test. Make it plain and simple.

Some employers make a glaring mistake when they identify an employee who is acting in such a way that a reasonable suspicion test is required. (Same goes for post-accident testing.) They either tell the employee to go on his/her own to the collection site or they tell the employee to finish working and then go to the collection site. In either case, the employer is risking potential legal liability. All you need is a subsequent accident on the job or on the way to the collection site and you are up to your armpits in litigation. Bottom line: if you think a reasonable suspicion test is required, take the employee yourself to the collection site or have a collector come to the work-site.

On-Site Collection
Every employer should seriously consider having the urine specimen collection conducted at the job site. Many TPAs train and employee individuals who can conduct urine specimen collections and breath alcohol tests outside a clinic environment, right on the jobsite. This prevents the employees being tested from having any opportunity to obtain adulterants, clean their urine, or develop excuses for why they could not make it to the clinic. Additionally, the cost of an on-site collection may not be as expensive as it may appear initially. Don’t forget to factor in the cost related to having two or three employees on the clock, but not working while they go to a clinic for a drug test. If the average salary is $30.00 per hour and the round trip to the clinic plus the time spent providing the sample averages out to three hours; three employees taking a drug test will cost you $270.00 in non-productive work time. On-site testing could bring that down by a third.

Getting back to the GAO and the Oregon State Police data; what does it indicate? There is some difference between the Oregon data and what DOT and Quest Diagnostics are reporting. There probably are some problems at collection sites and there are employees who will try to subvert the system. You can’t catch everyone who is trying to cheat, but you can certainly make it a lot harder. Will these few simple actions on your part improve the actual urine specimen collection process? Probably not significantly, but it may decrease the ability of certain individuals to “plan” on how to overcome a drug test. It is important that you don’t give them that extra time and opportunity when you notify them about an upcoming test. A little effort on your part will save you money in the long run.

About the Author
Don Shatinsky Former Senior Drug and Alcohol Policy Advisor at DOT, one of the authors of the Federal drug/alcohol testing regulations (49 CFR Part 40), and now a consultant in the drug testing field and a Regional Representative for Concorde, Inc. The opinions expressed in this Blog are for educational and informational purposes only. Any personnel or legal actions should be based on the actual rule text.

Post-Accident Testing

POST-ACCIDENT TESTING WHAT DO THE FEDS WANT?
By Don Shatinsky
Former Senior Drug and Alcohol Policy Advisor at DOT and one of the authors of the Federal drug/alcohol testing regulations (49 CFR Part 40), now a consultant in the drug testing field and a Regional Representative for Concorde, Inc. The opinions expressed in this Blog are for educational and informational purposes only. Any personnel or legal actions should be based on the actual rule text.

ACCIDENTS HAPPEN – RIGHT?

You bet, that’s why they are called accidents, and you have no control over them. What you do have control over is what happens following the accidents. Do you wind up doing something stupid that may result in fines and/or litigation or do you know what to do and stay out of trouble?
Just a Note: we are talking here about the highway industry. Approximately 90% of the Department of Transportation (DOT) drug and alcohol testing is in this category. Post-accident testing for aviation or rail is significantly different, but comprises only a small percentage of the over all transportation testing.

All good questions and the following will hopefully help you sleep better. There are really two decisions you have to make:
· The accident meets DOT criteria, or
· The accident does not meet DOT criteria

Simple, right? No, because many safety managers test everyone and then try to sort out if it was supposed to be a DOT test or non-DOT test.

Remember this!!! To apply this simple rule, you have to know which drivers are covered by DOT regulations. Again, simple, but there are still managers and supervisors who miss the boat.


Your driver comes under Federal regulations if:
The driver is using a commercial driver’s license (CDL); and
Operates a commercial motor vehicle (CMV) that has a gross vehicle weight rating of 26,001 pounds or more; or
Drives a vehicle designed to transport 16 or more passengers, including the driver; or
Drives a vehicle of any size used in the transportation of materials found to be hazardous under the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act and is required to be placarded under 49 CFR Part 172, subpart F.

One last two-step process. Drivers who are subject to post-accident testing are those who:
While performing safety-sensitive functions (i.e., driving a CMV) are involved in an accident resulting in a loss of human life, or While performing safety-sensitive functions are involved in a nonfatal accident resulting in the driver receiving a citation under State or local law for a moving traffic violation arising from the accident.

The question that frequently comes up is that the citation by law enforcement is not issued until the next day; say 12 hrs after the accident. What is the employer to do? For drugs you have up to 32 hours following the accident to perform the test. However, since the 8-hour window for alcohol testing has passed, you cannot test for alcohol. Once the clock runs out, you may not conduct any DOT testing.

Why is it important to determine if a test is supposed to be a DOT test or one under company policy? Because the government has limited authority to order an individual to provide a urine specimen for a drug test. When a company conducts a test using the Federal Chain of Custody Form, the company is notifying the driver or employee that the government is requiring this test. If it was supposed to be a non-DOT test, the government gets very unhappy – because you as an employer are misrepresenting their authority – and they have no problems levying fines for such actions on your part. Enough said; play by the rules and you should not be afraid of an audit.

Couple issues to remember. If you don’t do the alcohol test within 2 hours you must maintain a record of why the test could not be performed; then you have up to 8 hours in which to try and conduct the breath alcohol test – and again document why it could not be done earlier. The same goes for a drug test: if you cannot perform a drug test within the 32 hr. time frame you need to document the reason(s) and maintain that file.

And finally, drivers subject to post-accident testing must refrain from using alcohol for 8 hours following the accident or until completing a post-accident alcohol test, whichever comes first. It is imperative that the employers provide drivers with necessary post-accident information, procedures, and instructions prior to their operating a CMV, so that they and the employer will be able to comply with the rules.

Bottom line – know the rules and follow them!

 
nosoyelunicoboludodeannteojos | Copyright © 2012: